Should a Non-Mormon Move to Utah?

While my initial response to this question is “ARE YOU INSANE?” that’s just my knee-jerk reaction kicking in. See, I received the following question on my blog, and I will try to answer it to the best of my ability.

I have one question for you, I am a non-mormon with young non-mormon children. We are thinking of moving to Utah. My wife feels a little uncomfortable about being an outcast. Do you think we would encounter this

Well, if you move to, say, Park City, then NO, it shouldn’t be a problem at all. Salt Lake City is fairly moderate and liberal, too. But anywhere else, yes, you will encounter some problems and issues. That said, it’s not that the Mormons aren’t nice people. Most of them are. It’s just there are too many of them all living together, and whenever that happens, they tend to take on a mob mentality. Or at the least, a similar “blinders-on” mentality. They don’t see their actions as offensive. I think Utah would be a great place to live, if it weren’t for this, and that stinky smell that comes off the Great Salt Lake sometimes. Oh, and the inversion.

But the BO (not related to the stinky odor, but rather, referring to Blinders On)mentality was evidenced when the primary president showed up at my door and asked for my daughter, who is 10, never bothering to introduce herself or tell me her intent. This woman, I know, did not mean harm. I had someone comment on what a big meanie I was because I was rude to someone that had only the best intent. Heh. First of all, I was not rude. I just asked her who she was, and why she was asking for my daughter.

I mean, come on. Turn it around. How would SHE react if I showed up on her doorstep, asked for her daughter, and invited her to MY church, the Church of the Living Anti-Christ? Or The True Church of the Child Bride? She’d have been pretty angry. Why is it she, and the people around her, and all the other Mormons, cannot see this? These are not neighbors or people who know me. If my neighbor came and invited me to Church (and this has happened) I would say no thanks. Sorry, not interested. Joke around, and then be done with it.

When the people I know come around asking for donations for Boy Scouts, for instance, I tell them if they will donate to my daughter’s dance team, I will donate to the Boy Scouts. They laugh, and leave, without donating money, of course.

But back to the question at hand. Would you feel left out, and your children be left out, as a non-Mormon in Utah? Of course.

They put fliers on every door announcing church meetings and ward functions. They don’t stop to ask who is Mormon, and who is not. They just figure everybody is Mormon, or wants to be Mormon, or, for hell’s sake, SHOULD be Mormon! After all, it’s God’s true church!

Even out-of-state Mormons are disparaging of Utah Mormons. One of my harshest critics practically beat me up the side of the head because I didn’t seem to realize there is a real difference between Utah Mormons and other Mormons. Do the Utah Mormons know the other Mormons think they are big losers? And if so, would this set off some big divide where the church had to split, or Gordon would have to tell all the kids in the sandbox to play nice?

But despite the differences between the OMs(Out-of-State-Mormons, or perhaps even just Other Mormons) and UMs (Utah Mormons), they still band together when it comes to non-Mormons–whom they regard in a gentle, kindly, slightly condescending light, because these people are not going to the Celestial Kingdom. They also stick together against the ex-Mormons, who are generally reviled because they couldn’t live the commandments, and got offended by somebody, so they had to leave.

Note to non-Mormon Guy thinking about moving to Utah: As far as Mormons are concerned, the ONLY reason someone would leave the LDS Church is because they simply could NOT live up to the standards or someone said something mean and they were offended. Having a half a brain, say, as a reason, and understanding that elephants did NOT exist in the Americas pre-Columbus, despite what the Book of Mormon says, just is not a valid reason.

So, while in moving here you will find that the people are nice, especially when they first meet you and you are a prospect for conversion, part of what happens to non-Mormons in Utah is inevitable and avoidable.

See, the problem with teaching your children that you have the only true religion is that they have a tendency to want to repeat what YOU have drilled into their heads from birth.

In third grade, one of my daughter’s classmates asked her why she wasn’t Mormon. She replied, “I’m Christian.”

“Oh, well, Christians don’t have the true religion. Mormons do,” he told her.

The teacher did not intervene or comment.

I called the school to complain, and the boy was called in, and the teacher (a Mormon)was called in and spoken to, and the principal (also a Mormon) was very apologetic, but when it was all said and done I found myself feeling sorry for the poor kid. I mean, for hell’s sake, he’s been taught ALL his life that Mormonism is true, and that you proclaim it loud and clear, and that you spread it to the world, and when you are 18 you have to go on a mission, and when he DOES proclaim it, he’s in trouble.

The big problem with teaching kids that there is only ONE true thing, and you have it, is that often they believe you. And repeat it. Sometimes where you don’t want it repeated. Kids are good at that.

Once, my friend who is a hairdresser was told this story by an appalled grandmother. “My granddaughter said to me, ‘Guess what grandma? My mom and dad smoke p-o-t.'”

Annnnyway, long story short, if you do move to Utah, and it’s not Park City or Salt Lake City, consider private school. Mormons don’t care much for those. They don’t NEED their own private schools. They have one. It’s called PUBLIC SCHOOL.


About Natalie R. Collins

Natalie has more than 30 years writing, editing, proofreading and design experience. She has written 20 books (and counting), has worked for the Sundance Film Festival, and as an investigative journalist, editor, and proofreader. She embraces her gypsy-heart and is following her new free-thinking journey through life. Follow her as she starts over and learns a bunch of life's lessons--some the hard way.
This entry was posted in Natalie's Posts. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Should a Non-Mormon Move to Utah?

  1. That’s sad, Natalie. Just the fact that CHILDREN are taught to be so narrow minded makes me sad. I can guarantee I won’t be going to Utah EVER.


  2. Anonymous says:

    Just a comment about out-of-state Mormons vs. in-state Mormons: I have lived both inside Utah and outside of Utah and have been an LDS church-goer in both places. I can guarantee you that the out-of-state Mormons only THINK they are less annoying than in-state Mormons. If anything, they are more holier than thou (where I lived, anyway). Believe me, the out-of-staters think they are first in line for the Celestial Kingdom because of their superior obedience to all of the Mormon commandments, especially the one that says Thou Shalt Not drink Coke or Pepsi. 😉 They are not like those slacker Utah Morms, nosiree. Don’t believe that they are not judgmental; they judge EVERYBODY, including the Utah Morms.


  3. Otremer says:

    I like the Jack Mormons. I’ve known a few. They really enjoy pissing off the devout Mormons. I remember this really attractive Mormon girl who looked like Elizabeth Smart (don’t they all?) who said she used to like to chew and spit tobacco back in her small Idaho town just to see how scandalized everybody acted.

    Another Jack Mormon said the fondest memories of his youth were leaving for Sunday Sacrament meetings with his father. Sometimes they even made it to Sacrament meetings before the fishing poles in the trunk of the car started calling and they had to stop at a fishing hole.

    Jack Mormons are some of the best adjusted Mormons I know. Yeah, they’re judgemental too. They hate Mormons who take the Mormon Church too seriously.


  4. Anonymous says:

    I don’t know where you were living that the Mormons had to advertise through fliers on your front door, but we were so desperate to leave the crazy atmosphere of Utah that we joined the ARMY. (For the record, I am Mormon, a convert at that, and very active here in Texas.)
    Utah is interesting, since it was founded by Mormons and settled by Mormons, they can’t remove the church from the state.
    The non-Mormons in Utah are so rabidly anti-Mormon that anything you say or do is going to be scrutinized for any attempt to convert the listener.
    The Mormons in Utah are so incredibly “sophisticated” about their religion that they want to appear above the commandments of the Church, including the bans on smoking, drinking, R-rated movies, etc. And they are scrutinizing you to make sure you are neither a “goody goody” nor a “Jack Mormon” (inactive member who doesn’t live the commandments).
    So yeah, I felt like I was constantly being judged and ridiculed in Utah. Both by the members and the non-members. Very irritating. The worst time for my church enthusiasm was the time I lived in “Zion”.


  5. Emily says:

    Well said. =)



  6. Kristin says:

    Absolutely not! My great-grandfather settled in Utah from Italy and never converted to the Mormon church-believe me we’ve all been punished for not converting. I have so much to say on the subject that I won’t even start, but believe me, this is a weird cult out here and we have plans to move.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s